Go Back   Starboard Forums > Free Forum > Looking for a 5.5-6.0 Freestyle sail that gets planning me like in 6.5 to 7.0 sail

Thread: Looking for a 5.5-6.0 Freestyle sail that gets planning me like in 6.5 to 7.0 sail Reply to Thread
Your Username: Click here to log in
Image Verification
Title:
  
Message:
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

Topic Review (Newest First)
10th June 2008 12:06 PM
Unregistered There will be maybe a few days until Severne riders answer this post...they may be in the Severne meeting 2008.

Hope they come on this...would be good to hear from them. I also like freestyle and would like to start having fun sooner.
Charles
6th June 2008 01:56 AM
jonthesailorman Hey Roger,
if you really want to spend all of that money on masts to increase the range of one sail then have at it because they're is nothing I'm gona be able to say to change your mind set on that. Let me remind you here that we're talking about freestyle sails here. Freestyle sails right now for the most part are designed with idea of wining competitions. To do this they need to be able to power the board and get it planing asap. Have you seen what the pros are using currently at light wind comps? The wind reports from Podersdorf where a supposed 12 knot average and those guys were on 5.7-5.4 and stuff. Thats ridiculous! Granted they're pros, but its possible. I was out the other day pumping onto a plane in 10-11 knot gusts with my 6.4 and 99 flare.
5th June 2008 07:43 AM
Unregistered
Clinton Filen? Ben Severne? any other sail designers out there??

Hi guys, I still think the original idea can be possible. We have genious behind our sport-

we have got to a final statement...its possible to have loads of power but maybe its not the best for freestyle (weight, handling, durability ect.)

Anyway, it still think its possible and answer as: YES, this sail planes 2 knots earlier than any other sails in the Freestyle range of all companies.

Remember back when people said...its impossible to have a board planning in 7 knots...when they finally appeared, they said...but they wont be fast as the normal ones. After a few years...we know that all race guys switched to Formula type boards as they got planning in 2 knots less than usual and were faster than the previous ones.

Hope Clinton or Ben can comment on this...or maybe a guy like Barry that sometimes get on this Forum.

I still think that as the Formulas appeared, as the Glide appeared...I think is possible to have a Freestyle sail that planes 2 knots less than a Hucker in the same size and with the best mast combination for early planning.

THats it...any brilliant ideas?

Marc
4th June 2008 11:04 PM
Roger Hi Jon,
You are correct, the Sailworks Hucker probably is not the best
"freestyle" sail, for many of the reasons you suggest, but
as far as "early planiing power" comparing a 5.6 m2 Hucker to your
6.4 Loco isn't a very valid comparison.
Also is your "local Hucker guy" fully cognizant of the wide range of ways you
can enhance or reduce the power in the Hucker sails by using different masts?
If he was to use a soft (Powerex wave 430 RDM) mast in his 5.6 m2 Hucker, he would get lots of top twist.
Change the mast to a Sailworks 430 Backbone RDM and the top of the sail tightens up significantly.
Use the mast the sail was designed for (Sailworks 430 Joystick 430 SDM) and you get a tight leech up in the top and a very deep foil down low.
Change again to a Sailworks Backbone 460 RDM and you get a lean/mean slalom foil with a slightly loose leech up top, but still some power up there as well.
So, I don't think comparing a 6.4 Loco to a 5.6 Hucker is really valid unless you use the entire range of masts.
I think I you compared the 6.6 m2 Hucker to your 6.4 Loco the outcome would be very different.
I can rig the 6.6 Hucker to get planing at about the same threshold as the 7.5 Retro.
Hope this helps,
4th June 2008 08:24 PM
jonthesailorman I've put a lot of thought into this idea myself a little while back. Unfortunately I'm pretty sure it doesn't work that way a lot of the time. The reality of it is that sails that are built like the Hucker are (i.e. super tight leech), feel like they have loads more power than a sail of equal size. In fact they feel like they offer power equivalent to sails a full meter up in size. The truth of it though can be found in our formula friends in form of a clever phrase, "there is no replacement, for displacement". Granted this idea is used a bit differently by them but it has merit throughout the sport. It doesn't matter what sail size you are using, if you don't have enough wind for it, your not going anywhere. Now I'm not saying that 5.8 Hucker-esque freestyle sail wouldn't plane up more quickly then sails of a similar size, but I am saying that that it wouldn't plane up faster than a larger, 6.5ish early planing sail. I've seen it first hand. There has been many days were I was getting going most of the time on my 6.4 Loco popin' freestyle everywhere, and the local Hucker guy rigged up his 5.6 and didn't get going at all. Not even once. You like he'd learn. And further more, the sail properties that make a Hucker a Hucker are not properties I would look for in a freestyle sail. Huckers work the way they do because of a super tight leech and a full power outline. Sails like this don't neutralize super easily, full power outline makes them more difficult to toss around. Having a fat sail foot provides low end power, but is very difficult to get around for rig ducking. The super high tension gives a tight leech, but needs heavy reenforcement to hold it together during abuse. This also makes a sail feel very heavy, not what you need for freestyle. I think the current freestyle sails out there right now fit the bill, and that a little bit a looking is all your going to have to do to find the right one for you. Thats just my 2cents though.
3rd June 2008 12:37 PM
Unregistered I think Ricardos question is different than the answers received, and as I understand, the question might be:

considering the Sailworks Tucker and the Maui Sails Loco, that are between different opinions the early existing freestyle sails...what about designing a sail that planes 2 knots less than them? or who can design for him a freestyle sail that planes 2 knots before them.

Making more obvious the question:

who can design a Tucker or Loco 5.8 that carries the planning ability of a Tucker or Loco 6.7, that maybe will carry the power of a 7.0 "average sail".

Looks like he is really serious about pushing freestyle and the idea looks good for me too.

Luke Joy
30th May 2008 10:38 PM
jonthesailorman I asked Taty a question regarding some differences in freestyle sails he's used. Heres what he had to say.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Taty Frans View Post

The Echo's is basically a pure freestyle sail, before I change to Mauisails I have helped design the 2004 echo's.. If you remember they where already 4 battens. the 5.2 5.6 6.0 where great sails. very light, short boom, and handling was very easy and doing tricks was very easy. I still believe these sails are the best freestyle sails I have helped design and sailed with untill now.


So the loco's are basically the same concept as the echo's but with a slightly better planing ability. the power of the sail is more improve. so this get you going in the lighter winds. and it's a 5 batten freestyle sail.

If you need to compare the (2008) Echo's V.s The (2008) Loco.

I would say that the Echo's have been getting shorter at boom, the sail feels very light and small, like when I sailed with Kiri 4.8 echo I felt like I was sailing with a slightly smaller sail. but that's great because it make's you go for every moves.

On the loco's 4.8 it kinda have the same feeling of the Echo BUT the loco have a better planing ability. that's what I like better then echo's.
When I was on Mauisails I used to sail with a smaller size of sail then Tonky, like if Tonky is on a 5.2 I was on the 4.8. I could have even use almost use the same sail sizes that kiri is using at a windy day.

To tell you the truth I have never really sailed with the 5.6 Loco on Bonaire because the 5.2 was enough.

Taty Frans NB-9
hope Taty doesn't mind me posting this. I found it useful I think you will too. I've been ridding on mauis for a while now. I use a 6.4 to get going really early in stupid light wind, 12 knots is possible. I'll use the 5.6 in about 16. they also come in 6.0

p.s. stay clear of huckers for freestyle. They are REALLY HEAVY!
29th May 2008 01:41 PM
PG The most powerful sail in the 6 m2 range is probably the Severne Gator. It has at least got rave reviews for early planing.
29th May 2008 11:42 AM
Unregistered I will make my question clearer...considering there are sails actually with more power than others (like the ones you mentioned), I would like a sail that have the power to do the same than THOSE POWERFULL actually existing sails with 2 knots less.

Say, if with the actual POWERFULL SAILS for freestyle I can get out and have fun in 14 knots, I would like to see the chance to go freestyling in 12 knots with the same size about 5.8 sail.

I think sounds weird my idea, but I also remember 1998 when saying planning in 7 knots was impossible...after a few years the Formula boards came and wind planning need was reduced in 2 knots just changing the board design. And let me say that the first time I tried the Formula wide boards (85cm at that time) I was planning as with the race small boards but with a different feeling. I am not looking to keep the same exact feeling of an actual freestyle sail with a super powerfull say, just wondering if this is possible and in case is possible...try the feel and check if i prefer that feel having the advantage of sailing with 2 knots less (maybe 10% more days in my 3 hours drive by car spot and maybe 50% more days in my 10 minute drive by car spot ).

Ricardo
28th May 2008 10:24 PM
crazychemical gaastra remedy 6.0. These sails are built to keep you powered up but they still have a small enough boom to do tricks on them.
I also myself have an older NP Soul 6.2 freestyle sail and in powered up conditions with chop on my 113 this sail is perfect, it has big speed and can pull me out of the water for waterstarts. i suspect it's decendents (NP expression i think) has simular qualities. I got to test the expression 6.9 2005 version in leucate once but with a bad mast and boom so i didn't quite get the feel from it, but it got me going from around 15 knots up to 23 knots easily before i got too overpowered to sail it, and even then i just brought it in because by then i had broken my board, i think i could have pulled it up to 25 knots of wind.
I never tried any sailworks but from what i hear they are good. Though personally i'm a gaastra fan because of they userfriendly feel.

hope this helps
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


All times are GMT +7. The time now is 01:01 AM.