Similar thing happened to me but on a 2010 Futura. What I did was got my shop to order new pads under warranty. Mine was only a few months old before it started to peel.
Once I had the pads I pulled off the old one's, very easy considering there was very little glue holding it all down! I then marked the foot strap hole positions from the board onto the new pad. Cleaned down the board surface of all old glue, etc. and then glued the new pad down. I then drilled out the holes using a very small drill bit and then followed that with a sphere sanding drill bit to bevel in the holes. Worked perfectly and I believe a much better job then original. I have to agree with you, some pretty bad work quality wise on Starboard behalf!